Welcome Peeps and Creeps!

Reviews

Rate Show

Binged in a week and I’m really picky
I never leave reviews but they deserve it. At first I wasn’t sure if I liked the banter but I literally have listened to their entire catalog in a week (or less, I’m often alone at the office) and subscribed for their Patreon for bonus episodes and have been bingeing those. I really love this podcast. Even highly covered cases I thought I knew everything about, Kristen still finds a way to find information and give me a whole new set of facts I had never heard and literally give me a new opinion sometimes. She also doesn’t just cover true crime which I thought I wouldn’t like but actually really do. Mogab the other host who isn’t a true crime fanatic is so hilarious. I find myself cracking up with them so often which I personally like cause this genre gets dark. It doesn’t take away from the victims and isn’t done in unnecessary places. I also love that Kristen doesn’t divulge or elaborate on particularly gruesome things that we really don’t need to know.

New favorite podcast
This is the best true crime show, the cases are good & well researched. Not to mention the hosts are awesome, love them both!!

Best True Crime Podcast Out There
Have been listening to Kristen and Mogab for a couple years now, and it’s hands down the only true crime podcast I get excited for every week! They are HILARIOUS and their cases are very interesting and not your typical overly covered cases. True crime creepers is a must listen to podcast.

Favorite
Kristen and Mogab are my favorite true crime podcasters. Kristin writes and tells the stories and Mogab reacts and I know that simplifies it, but you have to listen to understand how magical that chemistry is.

Kristen and Mogab - my walking partners
Kristen is such a great story teller. You can tell how much she wants to do these episodes right by the amount of research that is involved. Mogab makes me laugh with questions and reactions to the information that Kristen is giving us. I especially enjoy that Samantha gives us a glimpse into her life and life with Russell and Burksie Boy.

BEST PODCAST EVER!
I love listening to you both so much! I never laughed out loud at a podcast until listening to yours. The absoluteeeee best! Please do an episode with Bailey Sarian 😍😍😍

XOXO
Love the podcast! This NJ mom (hey Russell hey) looks forward to my Thursday morning commute. Maybe too much because sometimes I wait until the podcast is over before strolling into work a little late. Kristen and Mogab’s chemistry is so genuine. It feels like I am catching up with friends and sprinkling in some current events and true crime during the chat. Kristen has the best laugh. It never seems like they are trying too hard to be funny or witty or “zany” like some other podcasts. Thank you ladies!

Favorite New True Crime Podcast!
I came across this after seeing a suggestion and I thought I would give it a listen before I subscribed and I’m so many episodes in and have already subscribed to the Patreon. Kristen and Mogab do a good job with research and keeping me interested, keep up with the good work ladies!

Love you both!
I have always loved Ttue Crime, crime shows, fictional crime! Your podcast has brought it all to obsession level. Your chemistry is off the chain. Thanks so much-PS loved the Jen K reference!

Hooked
I thought- ooh I’ll just listen to this one episode, it sounds good. Well here I am like 20 episodes deep…great job ladies!

Need friends? Say hello to your new besties
I started listening when they were about 50 episodes in and now I’m true crime obsessed. When I caught up to the latest episode I started looking for other podcasts and was disappointed. There really isn’t another like this. These two are my favorite to listen to as I can tell only the story is scripted. Thank you both for helping me get through busy weeks and providing me a fake social life - friends to gab with between meetings. Keep it up ladies!

Love True Crime Creepers!
This is my most favorite podcast that I can binge listen all day at work. They are tastefully playful with their back-and-forth banter, but also not annoying and have their side conversations take over the whole podcast.

Fabulous podcast
I love this podcast. The chemistry between the two hosts is fantastic—they balance each other out so well. Plus —the research on each case is exhaustive. Have you thought about Tiffany Sessions case in Gainesville Florida? Thank you keep up the fabulous work 🩷

Fave True Crime Pod!
I listen to lots of true crime podcasts but this is the first one I’ve actually taken time to review. I love that listening is just like hanging out and talking true crime with friends. I’m so happy I found your podcast on a recent New Year collab!, and I’m recommending to everyone!

I love you guys!
Every episode leaves me craving Waffle House!!! I love your podcast!

So glad!
So glad I found this podcast while searching for more discussions about the (bonkers) Natalia Grace case. These two are funny and have some interesting input on true crime. Thanks ladies!

NYNB was worth it!
I am an avid fan of The Trail Went Cold, and via their participation in New Year New Binge, I was introduced to True Crime Creepers. This show is very well done, with excellent pacing, good scripts, and genuinely funny banter. Keep it up, gals!

Loving it
They make me feel like I’m sitting in on a convo with friends. Perfect blend of humor, empathy, and good storytelling

AMAZING podcast!
These ladies are THE BEST at telling stories respectfully but humorously. If you like (the old/original) Morbid, My Favorite Murder, etc., you’ll love it. I’d never thought twice about Scott Peterson and the POSSIBILITY of his innocence until the facts I heard here, confirmed by lots of further research. The empathy in the Andrea Yates episode made me cry. And you’re right, Lou Pearlman DOES look like a thumb. I also love that they’re from my hometown area and then went to college just south of where I did (UT Austin vs Texas State/frmly SWT) so a lot of the references are local. Hook em, and Eat em Up Cats.

Underrated!
This is my new favorite podcast. I’m so happy I stumbled upon it. They remind me of the girls from Sinisterhood. Very underrated - can’t wait for new episodes!

New Fave!
I enjoy the banter (and I normally hate tangents during a story) but I do appreciate the commentary with these two. I’m about to go ahead binge this show.

Best podcasters ever
I love you gals. You always. Are me laugh and you do a great job in telling these stores.

Love this one
I love the two parters. I prefer the deep dives vs. a 20 minute story. I like to be absorbed into a story. This podcast delivers. One of my favorites for sure.

LOVE!
I’m on episode 2 I already love the podcast! I was trying to find a good true crime podcast after I stopped listening to morbid. I finally found one that I enjoy listening to!

Fav true crime pod
100% my fav true crime podcast! Love how Kristen tells stories, she’s so intelligent and considerate. And Mogab is the perfect comic relief. SO happy to have her back from her wedding hiatus. I’ve been listening from the start and it made me well up when I heard your first ad. Im SO happy you guys are getting paid to do this podcast—you deserve it!! 🤍🤍🤍

Love love love
Omggggg I loveeee you guys. My new favorite. Please don’t ever leave me 🤣

Love!
So glad I found this!

Everyone knows Jodi Messina
Great show but K needs to get it together with her 90’s country.

BEST EVER!!!!!!
One day I was randomly searching for a podcast to listen to and I found this one. One episode, that’s all I needed to become obsessed. I needed to listen from the beginning to the most recent, it’s all I listen to on my free time. I’m telling everyone that I know that listens to podcast to listen to it. I love it.

Natalia
You covered this horrific story with integrity, unlike Hulu or netflix. Sure framing it as a possible “orphan” scenario is more gripping, but absolutely disgusting. Natalia was a victim of the Barnetts and the whole system. They should’ve gone to prison. I like your fire!